Why Donors Give: The Influence of Leadership Over Mission
Written by Alex Sejdinaj, Founder & CEO
When it comes to why donors choose to give to a nonprofit, many might assume that the mission of the organization is the primary driver. After all, the cause is what the nonprofit stands for, right? But, increasingly, research and real-world examples show that donors are more likely to open their wallets based on the person leading the organization—the Executive Director (ED)—rather than the nonprofit's mission alone.
The Power of Leadership
Donors are drawn to people they trust. The Executive Director serves as the face of the nonprofit, embodying its values, mission, and vision. When donors meet the ED or hear them speak, they get a sense of whether the leader is someone capable of managing their contributions effectively. It's not just about charisma—although that can help—but about credibility, transparency, and shared values.
A study by the Lilly Family School of Philanthropy found that donors place a significant amount of trust in nonprofit leaders, especially in small and medium-sized organizations. This trust often supersedes their attachment to the specific cause. Why? Because leadership reassures them that their money will be well-spent, creating tangible results. Even if the mission is compelling, donors want to ensure the person steering the ship has a clear direction and the ability to turn vision into impact.
The Personal Connection
In many cases, the Executive Director has a personal story or passion that connects deeply with potential donors. People give to people, not just causes. A compelling story from the ED—whether it's their journey into nonprofit leadership, their personal connection to the issue at hand, or their relentless drive to make change—can be more persuasive than any mission statement.
Moreover, donors like to feel as though they're building a relationship with the organization, and that relationship often begins with the leader. The ED represents a point of access, making the donor feel more involved and appreciated.
Mission is Still Important—But It’s Amplified by Leadership
Of course, the mission of the nonprofit still matters. It's the reason the organization exists in the first place. But leadership adds a human dimension to the mission. The ED is the person who makes the mission come alive, showing how it can be achieved through strategy and action. When donors see a strong leader, they see someone who can mobilize a team, navigate challenges, and ensure that their dollars make a meaningful difference.
In fact, a great leader can elevate a mission that may be less well-known or niche by showcasing its urgency and importance. A strong ED can bring clarity to the mission, articulating it in a way that resonates emotionally and practically with donors, especially those unfamiliar with the cause.
Building Trust in Leadership: A Key to Sustainable Giving
If your nonprofit is trying to increase donor engagement and giving, it’s worth investing in the visibility and credibility of your leadership team, particularly your Executive Director. Ensuring that the ED is not only skilled in operations but also able to effectively communicate the mission and vision is key.
This can be done through:
Storytelling: Encourage your ED to share their personal story and how they connect to the cause.
Public Engagement: Make your ED accessible to donors, whether through events, direct communication, or even social media.
Transparency: Donors want to trust that their money is being put to good use. Openly sharing successes, challenges, and future goals will build that trust.
Relationship Building: Encourage your ED to form personal relationships with key donors. This personal touch often tips the scale toward continued, substantial giving.
Conclusion
While a nonprofit’s mission provides the foundation, it’s the leadership—particularly the Executive Director—that inspires trust and encourages donors to give. People are more likely to support a cause when they believe in the person driving the change. Investing in strong, transparent leadership can make all the difference in your nonprofit’s fundraising success. So, if you're looking to attract more donors, don’t just highlight what you do—highlight who’s leading the way.
GiveGrove makes events and auctions for fundraising easy. Check us out at GiveGrove.com or email info@givegrove.com for more info. Click here to sign up for our mailing list.
